No-Bake Vegan & Paleo Pumpkin Cheesecake

by | Oct 11, 2016

Freshly roasted pumpkin. Creamy rich coconut butter. Super simple, healthy, no-bake cheesecake. WHAT???

Dairy-free, gluten-free, refined sugar free, soy-free vegan, paleo… you name it, I got you covered with this one. Absolutely delicious? You better believe it!

Pumpkin pie was always my favorite Thanksgiving dessert. I know, I know, Thanksgiving is still over a month away, and this isn’t actually pumpkin pie. But come on, when something is this yummy and this healthy, I don’t care if it’s the middle of July, I would totally make it!

Plus, this is SO much better than any ole pumpkin pie! It just tastes like fall, and with it being super healthy you can make it like 5 (or 10!) times before Thanksgiving and it totally be okay.

The crust is super simple. I actually use it as a base in just about all of my dessert creations (like these Sprouted No-Bake Cookies and my Easy Rhubarb Crumble). 4 ingredients is all you really need:

  • Coconut flour
  • Ground flax or chia seed
  • Coconut oil
  • Date paste

Mix them until they stick together and voilà! You’ve got a super easy, fiber and nutrient-rich crust (or cookie dough, or crumble topping…) that you can flavor up any way you want depending on what you’re making.

But we’re making pumpkin cheesecake, and we’ve got to have that super rich and creamy filling. One of the best parts about it is that you can do as much or as little of the pumpkin and coconut work as you want. Since there’s fresh pumpkins in season, my preference is to use those and either roast and steam because they’re so much better than the canned stuff! But, you can totally use the 100% pumpkin puree from a can or carton.

Same deal for the coconut butter. I LOVE grinding up my own coconut butter in my Vitamix, but you can buy either coconut butter or canned full-fat coconut milk and use instead.

Other than that, the filling is only Date Paste, molasses, and your choice of yummy fall spices.

Oh my goodness, so easy. This is your new favorite fall dessert! You’ll definitely be making this more than once before Thanksgiving.

Top it with whatever you’d like. I sprinkled on some extra crust that I mixed with sprouted buckwheat and pumpkin seeds, and of course had to drizzle on some molasses! Perfect!
No-Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake - Vegan and Paleo
Prep time
Active time
Total time
Serves: 1 cheesecake
For the crust:
  • Coconut flour (I use Nutiva)
  • Ground flax and/or chia seeds (I use Bob's Red Mill and Nutiva)
  • Date paste (find my how-to on the blog), thinned with a bit of water
  • Coconut oil, melted
  • Himalayan sea salt
  • Water
For the filling:
  • Sugar pie pumpkin, peeled and diced (or 100% pumpkin puree)
  • Coconut butter (Tip: I make my coconut butter in my Vitamix right before the filling for simplicity and less cleaning)
  • Date paste
  • Lemon, juiced (or keep whole/peeled if using something like a Vitamix)
  • Molasses
  • Spices of choice - cinnamon, ground ginger, cloves, or a pumpkin pie spice
  • Himalayan sea salt
  • Water, as needed
For the crust:
  1. Mix your coconut flour with about ¼ the amount of ground flax, chia, or a combination of both, and a pinch of salt. The amount of coconut flour to start with depends on how thick you want your crust. I generally begin with about 1 cup worth (or a good scoop) of coconut flour and then go from there. The flax and chia really help this crust stick together, while adding lots of great nutrients and texture!
  2. Drizzle in coconut oil, about ¼ the amount of flour used (just like in the filling, the fatty coconut helps this crust firm up once chilled).
  3. Add enough water to the date paste to make thinner, more like a syrup. Begin adding this date "syrup" to the mixture until it easily sticks together. Test your crust by pressing a handful between your fingers. If it falls apart, add more syrup. If it sticks together well, it's perfect.
  4. Press evenly into your springform pan and set in your freezer while making the filling. Make it as thick or thin as you like!
For the filling:
  1. If roasting your pumpkin, rub with coconut oil, cinnamon, and salt and roast on 400º, or broil, until golden brown. You can steam your pumpkin instead. Blend until smooth.
  2. To your blender add roughly equal parts pumpkin puree and coconut butter. The coconut butter will be what helps the cake solidify as it chills, so if it seems a bit thin, add extra coconut butter.
  3. It's your choice on the amount of molasses wanted. Maybe you don't want any at all, that's okay. Just use more date paste. I use about equal parts because I love the molasses flavor. If you're hesitant, begin with smaller amounts of both because you can always add more.
  4. Add (dump) in whatever spices you want, and however much. I love mine with a lot of spice, but begin with a few shakes and add more after blending and tasting if desired.
  5. Add in a squirt or two of lemon for that "cheesecake" tang, depending on what you like.
  6. Blend on high, slowly adding in water to help blend smoothly, careful not to add too much as it will not set up properly. Consistency should be super smooth and creamy, and still able to scoop or spread without being too thin (no "pancake batter" consistency).
  7. Taste. Is it sweet enough? Do you want more molasses or spices? Is there enough lemon for that "cheesecake" tang? Add more if needed and blend again.
  8. Pour this mixture over the crust in the springform pan and spread evenly. Place in freezer to set up until firm. Keep in the fridge.
If doing your own puree and butter you'll need a good blender, like a Vitamix. However, you can use store-bought puree and coconut butter or coconut cream and use a mixer to blend all ingredients instead.
*For those that are new here, I focus on showing how to create recipes without measurements and hope to encourage you to view my recipes, and all recipes, as inspiration. Not being confined and learning the "art" of creating your own! Please, contact me if you have specific questions.

Did you make it??? Head on over to my Instagram @noelle.parton and tag me if you try this out, or contact me below or here if you have questions or comments! Would love to hear from you!

God bless,

signature of me for simply to thrive

HELLO! Glad you're here!

I'm Noelle, creator of Simply to Thrive. A place where I share my love and passion for nutrition and wellness. learn more >


In-depth on the Health of the Church


Find me on IG @noelle.parton



No-Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake | INCREDIBLE & SIMPLE no-bake, vegan & paleo cheesecake! The best fall treat! |

© 2018 Simply to Thrive. All Rights Reserved. All photography and graphics are Noelle Parton originals unless noted.

get my  latest recipes straight to your inbox

and my FREE GUIDE to not needing a recipe!

You have Successfully Subscribed!